Dalton McGuinty, Great Lakes wind farms, noise impact, noise studies, offshore wind, Offshore Wind Farm noise impacts, offshore wind farms, offshore wind turbines, Ontario, Ontario Liberal, property values, wind farm Lake Erie, wind farm Lake Huron, wind farm Lake Ontario, wind farm moratorium
Just prior to the 2011 Ontario election, the Dalton McGuinty government announced a “moratorium” on offshore wind development. It was widely thought this move was to stave off any criticism (and lost votes) from Toronto, the Ontario Liberal stronghold, as there was significant opposition to a project proposed off the Scarborough area, where lake views are prized.
Now, it’s 2014, and the Liberals have a majority and four years ahead in power.
Last Friday, a request for proposal for a noise impact study for offshore wind “farms” was posted on MERX here.
echnical Evaluation to Predict Offshore Wind Farm Noise Impacts in Ontario
This Request for Proposals is an invitation to prospective proponents to submit proposals for the Technical Evaluation of Sound Propagation Modelling Methodologies to Predict Offshore Wind Farm Noise Impacts in Ontario.
Scope of Work
The Preferred Proponent will be required to conduct a technical evaluation of sound propagation modelling methodologies to predict Offshore Wind Farm noise impacts in Ontario (the “Study”), and create a report about the Study to the satisfaction of and for approval by the Ministry (the “Study Report”). The scope of work to be performed by the Preferred Proponent includes:
(i) Conducting a literature review and consulting technical and government specialists;
(ii) Preparing and submitting the Study Report based on the literature review and consultation;
(iii) Providing the chapters of the Study Report to the Ministry in draft form for review, comment and approval by the Ministry, and revising the chapters and final Study Report to the satisfaction of the Ministry; and,
(iv) Participating in kick-off meeting/teleconference and periodic teleconferences with Ministry staff as required.
Field measurements, validation testing and/or the purchase of Offshore Models are outside the scope of this study.
Note that this is essentially a literature review and actual noise measurement is “outside the scope”; we expect that the wind industry lobby will contribute heavily to this “study.”
Offshore wind power generation projects have been proposed for several areas in Lakes Ontario, Erie and Huron. Concerns about such development range from worries about noise (turbine noise produced at Wolfe Island is experienced across the water in New York State), damage to the lake beds, especially Erie, where the toxic substances have settled, and for property values of adjacent properties.
Email us at email@example.com
Reblogged this on Northgowerwindactiongroup's Blog.
Roger Graves said:
The Ontario government cannot, dare not, admit the slightest possibility that wind turbine noise can be harmful or in any way objectionable. To do so would open the floodgates to litigation by the hundreds, and possibly thousands, of people whose lives have been inconvenienced and sometimes uprooted by proximity to wind turbines. The resulting damages could bankrupt Ontario.
To gauge the extent of this, imagine that the effects we have seen reported were due, not to wind turbines, but to nuclear or coal-fired power stations. The media would be frothing at the mouth, environmental groups would be denouncing anything and everything within reach, and packs of feral lawyers would be prowling the streets, salivating at the thought of all those class action suits. Damages could easily be in the tens of millions per plaintiff.
I can predict with 100% certainty the outcome of the study: no deleterious effects, nothing to see here, move along folks. Why don’t you just give me the money, Ms Wynne, and I’ll write the executive summary for you right away.
Absolutely dead on.